Editorial illustration. Not a photograph.
By World Media Feed Editorial Team
The International Court of Justice is set to deliver a landmark judgment on November 19 in the case brought by The Gambia against Myanmar over alleged violations of the Genocide Convention in its treatment of the Rohingya.
The ruling will be one of the most closely watched decisions involving the 1948 Genocide Convention in years. It will also test how the world’s principal court for disputes between states evaluates evidence of genocidal intent, state responsibility and the consequences of mass violence against a civilian population.
Importantly, the Court has not yet ruled that Myanmar committed genocide. That is one of the central questions before the judges.
How the case reached the World Court
The Gambia filed the case in November 2019, arguing that Myanmar had violated its obligations under the Genocide Convention through its treatment of the Rohingya, a predominantly Muslim ethnic minority from Rakhine State.
The case followed Myanmar’s 2017 military operations in Rakhine State, which drove more than 730,000 Rohingya across the border into Bangladesh, according to estimates cited by Reuters. Survivors and international investigators reported killings, sexual violence, village destruction and other abuses. Myanmar has rejected the genocide allegation and has described its military campaign as a counter-insurgency operation.
In January 2020, the ICJ ordered provisional measures requiring Myanmar to take measures within its power to prevent acts covered by the Genocide Convention and to preserve evidence. Those measures were not a final finding that genocide had occurred.
In July 2022, the Court rejected Myanmar’s preliminary objections and found that it had jurisdiction to hear the case and that The Gambia’s application was admissible. The decision allowed the proceedings to move forward to the merits.
What the judges must decide
The legal question is more specific than whether serious atrocities took place. Under the Genocide Convention, genocide requires certain prohibited acts committed with the specific intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
That makes intent a critical issue. The Court will examine the evidence and determine whether it meets the legal threshold required to establish Myanmar’s responsibility under the convention.
The distinction matters because international crimes can be established under different legal standards. Evidence of killings, forced displacement or other grave abuses does not automatically establish genocide. The Court must consider both the acts alleged and the required intent.
Reuters reported ahead of the judgment that legal experts will closely watch how the judges assess patterns of conduct, evidence from UN investigations and allegations involving killings, sexual violence, forced displacement and harm to children.
Why the ruling matters beyond Myanmar
The case has attracted international involvement because its interpretation of the Genocide Convention could influence how states and courts approach similar disputes.
Several countries have participated in the proceedings under the Court’s intervention procedures, including Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, the Maldives and Slovenia. Their participation reflects broader interest in how the convention’s provisions are interpreted.
The ruling is also being watched for possible implications beyond Myanmar. Reuters reported that legal experts are examining the judgment for clues about how the Court may approach other genocide-related proceedings, including South Africa’s case against Israel concerning the war in Gaza. That does not mean the cases are legally identical; each proceeding turns on its own evidence, allegations and legal arguments.
The distinction between the ICJ and the ICC
The Myanmar case also highlights an important distinction that is sometimes lost in coverage of international justice.
The International Court of Justice settles disputes between states. It can determine whether Myanmar bears international responsibility under the Genocide Convention and can address questions of remedies.
The International Criminal Court, by contrast, prosecutes individuals accused of international crimes. An ICJ judgment therefore would not itself sentence individual military or political leaders.
What the judgment could mean for the Rohingya
For Rohingya communities, the legal proceedings are closely connected to a humanitarian crisis that has continued for years.
More than a million Rohingya refugees are living in Bangladesh, while Rohingya communities remain in Myanmar amid continuing conflict and restrictions. The 2017 violence created one of the world’s largest refugee crises, and prospects for safe, voluntary and dignified return remain uncertain.
A judgment in The Gambia’s favor would represent a major legal finding about Myanmar’s responsibilities under the Genocide Convention. But it would not, by itself, solve the refugee crisis or guarantee safe returns.
The Court’s ruling will also be closely examined for any discussion of reparations, prevention and other remedies sought by The Gambia.
A seven-year legal process reaches a critical point
The case has moved through several stages since it was filed in 2019. After the provisional measures in 2020, the Court’s 2022 judgment cleared the preliminary objections and established that the proceedings could continue. Written pleadings and interventions followed, leading to public hearings on the merits in January 2026.
The Court then entered deliberations. According to the Court’s schedule, judges will begin reading the judgment publicly on November 19 at 8 a.m. GMT at the Peace Palace in The Hague.
What to watch on November 19
The headline question will be whether the Court finds Myanmar internationally responsible for violations of the Genocide Convention. But the reasoning behind the decision may prove just as important.
- How the Court assesses genocidal intent: The judges’ treatment of intent could become a major reference point for future cases.
- How evidence is evaluated: The judgment may explain how patterns of violence, UN investigations and other evidence contribute to the legal finding.
- What remedies are ordered: The Court’s treatment of reparations, prevention and other requested measures will matter for the next phase of the dispute.
- What the decision means internationally: Governments and legal experts will examine the ruling for broader implications for the Genocide Convention.
For the Rohingya, however, the significance of the judgment extends beyond legal precedent. After years of displacement and uncertainty, the decision will represent the most consequential state-level judicial assessment yet of the allegations surrounding Myanmar’s treatment of the community.
World Media Feed will continue following the judgment and its implications after the Court delivers its decision.
Sources
- International Court of Justice — The Gambia v. Myanmar case materials
- International Court of Justice — July 2022 Judgment on Preliminary Objections
- Reuters — World Court to rule in Rohingya genocide case on November 19
- Reuters — How the Myanmar ruling could affect other genocide cases
- Reuters — How genocide is proven in court
Featured image: Editorial illustration generated for World Media Feed. Not a documentary photograph.